The
comic strip as an art form has been unfairly judged
throughout the decades. Since it creation in 1892, the medium has been called
"subversive trash", "overly juvenile" or "sub
literature". The purpose of a comic strip, Schulz liked to say, was to
make people laugh and to sell newspapers. Still in spite of himself, Schulz
continued to uphold the comic genre as a mirror of American contemporary society,
reflecting the highest of human dreams to the lowest of human fears. His work
is often described in philosophical, religious and psychological contexts.
Comic books were perceived to have been written for children. Newspaper comic
strips were recognized as something that could be read by everyone. They were
easy to decode and the words were added to make messages even easier to
understand. The creation of Superman by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster introduced
a new tradition in heroic storytelling. During WWII, comic books featured
patriotic heroes led by Captain America. After the war, they dealt with animal
stories, romance comics, crime and horror titles. Richard F. Outcault was influential in developing
the early "kid strips" through his lovable "Yellow Kid" and
"Buster Brown".
Other artists who contributed to the development of
the "child strip" included Gene Byrnes and Perscy Crosby, whose
characters, "Reg'lar Fellars" and "Skippy" were the comic
strip equivalents of Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn. Milt Caniff and Al Capp were
considerable influences on the early works of Charles M. "Sparky"
Schulz. But the man who influenced him the most was Roy Crane with his drawings
of "Wash Tubbs" and "Captain Easy". Crane's hilarious style
laid the groundwork for many cartoonists who followed him. When Schulz was old
enough to read the newspaper funnies with his dad, he began to study the
"Krazy Kat" strip by George Herriman. Schulz later admitted that a
book collection of "Krazy Kat" cartoons published in the 1940s did
much to inspire him to create a comic strip that went beyond the simple actions
of ordinary children. James Swinnerton's "Little Jimmy" established
the gentle child character who was later revived in 1950 by Schulz in
"Li'l Folks",
Schulz's innovative "Peanuts" comic strip was unlike anything
previously published and earned its unequaled place in American culture as well
as in comic history. In it, Schulz expanded the comic from one panel to a strip
format. The new strip format was different from other "kid strips" of
the time in that each strip dealt with only a brief incident and didn't have to
be followed daily. (Schulz was aware that the readers' habits were changing).
The four panel nature of "Peanuts freed Schulz from the group montage
format of "Li'l Folks", and allowed him to grow as a storyteller.
Instead of one-liner, single-panel gags, he could now develop situations for
the characters that went from a to b, then c and d. Schulz was aware of the
shrinking space available in newspapers and created a strip with four equal
panels that a newspaper editor could reproduce in three different forms.He
could run it horizontally, or he could drop one panel beneath another and run
it vertically. Also he could drop the last two panels beneath the first two and
run the strip in the form of a square.
Each of the panels on these
"Peanuts" strips is drawn 5 1/2 inches high by 6 1/2 inches wide in
the original. Schulz needed the large working space to be able to get the
proper expressions and to make his lettering clear. "Peanuts" is
greatly reduced in size for publication, and Schulz had to work exclusively
with the pen and used the brush only to place the dark areas, such as on
Snoopy's ears or Lucy's hair. The strip with its small size and matching name,
was marketed as the flexible format for any newspaper. It significantly
impacted the styles of other newspaper cartoonists and editors, thereby marking
its valuable place in comic history.
In the beginning, little attention was given to the insightful text and cute
little drawings that Schulz created. It took several years for readers to grow attached
to the "Peanuts" gang. But fifty years later, "Peanuts" has
become one of the most popular and longest running comics of all time. Schulz
created a total of 18,170 strips. However, it was not the comic strip that
guaranteed Schulz's place in history. In 1965, Schulz's story "A Charlie
Brown Christmas" was animated for television.
The show was a sensation and
when it was replayed in 1969, fifty-five million viewers tuned in. On that one
night, he reached a larger, more diverse audience than any other single popular
artist in American history.
The "Peanuts" franchise was an incredible success. " A Charlie
Brown Christmas" and other "Peanuts" classics became holiday
regulars and winners of Emmy and Peabody awards. The "Peanuts"
characters have appeared in marketing campaigns for MetLife and the Ford
Falcon. In 1960, Hallmark began producing "Peanuts" greeting cards.
Camp Snoopy began in Knotts Berry Farm and has become a common site at several
theme parks. The "Snoopy" character has appeared in Holiday on Ice
and in national museums. He was also featured in the Guinness Book of World
Records after the comic strip sold to its 2000th newspaper in 1984.
"Peanuts" has also appeared on the covers of Time, Saturday Review,
Newsweek, and other major magazines. The strip has had a profound and lasting influence
on the way people saw themselves and the world in the second half of the
twentieth century. Charles Schulz went from artist and storyteller to a
worldwide industry. He was the first newspaper cartoonist to receive this level
of success. He was most proud of Charlie and Snoopy's involvement with the
Apollo 10 Lunar Expedition in 1969. The command module for this mission was
named "Charlie Brown" and the lunar module "Snoopy". When
the lunar module successfully redocked with the command module, the report came
back over the radio to mission control that "Snoopy and Charlie Brown are
hugging each other". Of all the objects in the strip, Charles Schulz was
the proudest of Linus's security blanket.
He said, "I may not have
invented the term, but I like to think that I helped make it part of our
language". At the peak of Schulz's popularity, "Peanuts" reached
three hundred and fifty-five million readers and the merchandising of the brand
created a franchise unlike any other comic. It is reported that Charles M.
Schulz's income during his lifetime totaled more than $1.1 billion. Schulz died
in 2000 and was posthumously given the Congressional Gold Medal, the highest
honor given to a civilian. Throughout the history of the "Peanuts" strip,
Charles Schulz drew each frame singlehandedly. He requested in his will that
the "Peanuts" characters remain as authentic as possible and that no
new comic strips based upon them be drawn by another artist.
"Peanuts" permanently changed the post-war newspaper strip in other
ways as well. While the majority of early "kid strips" had featured
all male characters, Schulz changed the genre by stating as a major theme the
battle of the sexes, in which the self-assertive Lucy continually challenges
and beats the self-doubting Charlie Brown. In the early episodes, Lucy is
presented as a forerunner of the women's movement while Charlie Brown becomes
the symbol of the sensitive male of the 1960s.
Schulz revived the dying
"child strip" of the 1940s by introducing psychologically complicated
characters in the unexpected form of children. We were introduced to Charlie
Brown who fails in almost all he attempts to do, Lucy who represents female
superiority and Snoopy, the super-realist and detached observer.
"Peanuts" continually evolved with the turbulent years of the 60s.
After Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in 1968, Schulz added Franklin,
an African Americn character.
Franklin |
No critical analysis of Schulz's work would be complete without re-emphasizing
that the "Peanuts" strip was not written to be enjoyed by children.
It was written for adults because adults have memories of what it was like to
be a child and can experience the cartoon on a deeper level. Schulz's theory
which he called '"removal of the lids" states that we are pretty much
what we are going to be early in our lives. Our personalities are established
by age 5 or 6. We are like boiling pots on a stove. When we are young the
adults keep the lids on, but as we grow older, the lids pop off and our true
characteristics come out. As we mature, we discover ways to protect ourselves
and emerge from the positions of fear and anxiety that we are forced into as
children. Reading "Peanuts" is a way of returning to childhood and
yet not being exposed to its unpleasantness because we have learned to deal
with the negative emotions we face in the adult world. Very little material
used in the strip comes from observations of real children. Most comes from
Schulz's own childhood memories. Because reading the "Peanuts" strip
involves us so directly, we are deeply drawn into the emotions expressed by the
children. The humor works to soften some of the disappointment and pain.
In defense of some of his more heart rendering episodes, Schulz writes,
"Some of my best ideas have come from a mood of sadness rather than a
feeling of well-being. Pleasant things are not funny. You can't create humor
out of happiness. There is nothing funny about the person who gets to kick the
football. Drama and humor come from trouble and sadness and mankind's
astounding ability to survive life's unhappiness". Why has Charlie Brown
with all his failures become such a worldwide success? I think it is because Charlie
Brown represents the basic feelings that we all share no matter how old we are.
His fans can identify with his insecurities, anxieties and doubts simply
because his daily struggles are often our own. Most people would admit that
when everything seems to go wrong in their livs, they often feel just like him.
Charlie Brown is almost always portrayed as a loser and the one who suffers
most. All readers can empathize with him since everybody has had experiences
that resulted in losing. We feel sorry for him because he is the person that
everything bad seems to happen to. We love him all the more because he never
seems to give up. We admire his perseverance and his eternal hope. We find him
decent and worthy of our pity.
The "Peanuts" comic strip works for us because it allows us to bond
with its characters. It is highly successful as a medium that deals with
complicated thoughts and feeling in a very basic way (through simple design and
the eyes of children). Although the characters are representative of American
culture, the strip succeeds because its themes are universal. It is also very
funny. What displeases me most about the "Peanuts" franchise has been
the extent to which the brand has been marketed. What originally made the
cartoon strip work was its subtle anger and cruelty. But every image of Snoopy
and the Peanuts gang showed smiling faces on greeting cards, mugs, t-shirts,
toothbrushes, watches and even blimps. There was no escaping the "cuteness"
of the characters. It is unfortunate that Charles Schulz, the artist, has been unsuccessful
in resisting the temptation to become Charles Schulz, the entrepreneur.
Throughout its fifty years of publication, "Peanuts" has recycled
over and over again the same themes in different circumstances. Charlie Brown's
baseball team never wins a game, Sally always get D-minuses on her exams, the
Great Pumpkin never shows, and the football always gets pulled away. And every
time it is pulled away we are reminded our own infantile behavior when we were
about Lucy's age. She can't help herself any more than we could. Since comic
strips are not graphic novels, but rather singular incidents, there are no
complex plots in this series. Each event is read independently of another, but
they all relate specifically to the character's unique personality. Schulz has
portrayed the concerns that all people have in dealing with love, rejection and
personal failure. The theme of unrequited love affects most of the major characters
(Charlie Brown for the little red-haired girl, Sally for Linus, Linus for his
teacher, Lucy for Schroeder).
Relationships are another important theme in the series. Snoopy and Charlie
Brown are good friends although they sometimes are annoyed at each other.
Charlie Brown has a slightly negative attitude towards Lucy because she’s always
is mean to Linus. Sometimes however, it seems that he genuinely cares about her.
Charlie's best friend in Linus. The two of them often support each other
through troubled times. When Sally was born, Charlie adored his baby sister. As
she got older, she started to annoy him. Charlie remains oblivious to the
flirtations of Peppermint Patty and Marcie. The relationship between Schroeder
and Lucy shows another side of her character. Lucy bosses Charlie Brown and
Linus around, but she is quite docile in the presence of Schroeder.
The "Peanuts" characters exist in an unrealistic world without adults.
They are given important things to say and a very grown up vocabulary. They experience
adult feelings and sometimes express their emotions in harsh terms. In the
first ever "Peanuts" strip it was envy that prompted Shermy to say,
"How I hate him" when referring to Charlie Brown.
The words shock us
but Schulz knew that children were capable of feeling intensely negative
emotions too. Charlie Brown and his dog Snoopy are the main characters surrounded
by family and school friends. They are a reflection of the American pop culture
of the times. Through their eyes we are no longer passive observers as we are
allowed to experience the basic feelings that we all share. The darker themes
of depression, anxiety, grief, rejection, failure and abandonment are more
easily accepted by the reader because we hear everything spoken by children and
delivered with Schulz's strong sense of humor. We do not take offense at
learning negative things about ourselves because we believe that children and
dogs are innocent and amusing, not serious and wise. The reoccurring elements
of the "Peanuts" strip include the kite-eating tree, Schroeder's
music, Linus's blanket, Lucy's psychiatry booth, Snoopy's doghouse, Woodstock,
the Red Barron, Joe Cool, the baseball games, the football attempts, the Great
Pumpkin, the Girl With The Red Hair. Schulz's genius was using these visuals
over and over again within the context of the "Peanuts" world and
keeping the series fresh and funny.
Charlie Brown (the lovable loser) is an example of the neurotic personality. He
suffers from depression and anxiety, which are often the result of being
victimize by the other characters. He usually gets blamed when things go wrong
and is constantly worrying about whether other people like him. Although he is
plagued by self-doubt or by the hurtful actions of others, he maintains an
endless determination and hope.
Snoopy exhibits an outgoing and daring personality. As Joe Cool, he is the life
of the party. Schulz believed from experiences with his own dog and through
observations in his neighborhood that dogs were smarter than their masters. He
therefore gave Snoopy the ability to think, which made him smarter than any
other cartoon dog. Letting Snoopy think and walk on his hind legs made him
superior to even the kids in the strip.
Lucy has taunted Charlie Brown for fifty years. She is "crabby" and
always complains about something. Typical portrayals of Lucy show her bossing
her friends, mocking Charlie Brown, and being nasty to her brother. Her advice
as a psychiatrist is usually uncaring, delivered by yelling and always
misguided.
Schroeder |
Showing and telling are both important parts of Schulz's comic strips. It is
the combination of image and text that causes the reader to evaluate the image
in context of the text and the text in context of the image. According to Scott
McCloud, comics use iconic images such as sparse representations of reality to
allow the reader to inject himself into the narrative. The picture within each
frame is simply a vehicle to visually attract our attention in order to bring
us into a space that has very little information. We fill the empty space by
bringing together the image and the text. Charlie Brown's "ordinary"
face with its minimal feature, half-circles for ears and nose, dots for eyes, a
line for a mouth would not be capable of delivering much information without
the accompaniment of words that give expression to his feelings. However, it is
this generic face that allows us all to identify with him and the problems he
faces In "Peanuts" the words are necessary tools for communication.
The words which are contained within Snoopy's bubbles help us to understand what
he is thinking. We have very little to say about Woodstock because (in the absence
of words) he communicates with us through a series of marks within his bubbles,
which are too abstract for us to understand.
Words and pictures are equally important in the "Peanuts" comic
strips. The picture is not full of information and is not realistically drawn.
When we read the words, we are drawn into the comic world and suddenly the
character's situations and emotions are animated in our mind's eye.
"Peanuts" is not an "action" comic. We have to rely on what
the cartoon character tells us because the drawing does not give us much
information. The world of the "Peanuts" characters emphasizes the
invisible world of thoughts, feeling, emotions and relationships.
Although Schulz is remembered for putting sophisticated words into the mouths
of his little kids, his most important innovations were his visual techniques.
When trying to understand what Linus says, it is important to notice that his
hair is always standing on end. The very first "Peanuts" strip
featured large white space and big funny faces. It invited the reader right
into the frame and contrasted sharply from the drawings of Krazy Kat and
Popeye. The faces of the characters in these series were too small to display
much emotion, so the text had to add humor and make the emotional connection.
By drawing characters with large uncluttered heads, Schulz was able to increase
the number of facial expressions that could be used in his comics, thereby
adding new information to his strip. Schulz believed that design plays an
important part in any comic drawing All elements within the frame were
important. When drawing a brick wall he tried to make it more interesting by
varying the size and colors of the bricks. He frequently added a corner of a house
or a corner of a garage into the panel to break up the squares into pleasing
areas.
The art throughout Schulz's comics is more towards the cartoon side of the
spectrum than the "realistic".
The fact that his characters' heads
are equal to the size of their entire bodies prevented them from doing some of
the more realistic things that a more normal style of cartooning would allow.
For example, how could his kids ever reach above their heads. The concept of a
dog who is capable of thinking and typing takes us beyond the realm of the real
world. As the "Peanuts" strip developed it took on a greater degree
of sophistication. It also took on a greater abstraction. Schultz was unhappy
with the way he had originally drawn Woodstock. When he reduced the character
to a few lines, he was happier with the result. The simplistic faces of
Schulz's characters allow the reader to recognize the expression that is on the
character's face. There is no confusion and the meaning of the cartoon is
easier to understand. Therefore, the simply drawn characters in
"Peanuts" appeal to a very inclusive audience. Its messages become more universal.
I have to say, I genuinely enjoyed reading this review. A lot of people have written about Charles Schulz and "Peanuts", and though I've never read any other papers myself, I felt that your review was organic and heartfelt.
ReplyDeleteI especially admire your attempt to try fitting all of the perspectives of "Peanuts" that had accrued over the 50 years, and how you even include your own opinion of the marketing on "Peanuts". Possibly my favorite bit of the whole review was when you mentioned how Schulz wanted the adults to see the strip, and how it was supposed to remind them of when they were a kid. You had written:
"Schulz's theory which he called 'removal of the lids' states that we are pretty much what we are going to be early in our lives. Our personalities are established by age 5 or 6. We are like boiling pots on a stove. When we are young the adults keep the lids on, but as we grow older, the lids pop off and our true characteristics come out. As we mature, we discover ways to protect ourselves and emerge from the positions of fear and anxiety that we are forced into as children."
It's certainly an interesting theory about the way we grow INTO our true personalities, rather than growing OUT of our childhood.
Overall, this was a really swell review, and I was glad to have read it!
This review at sometimes feels scattered, jumping awkwardly from one idea to another. It gets better and more focused as it goes along, but there are many observations about Schulz and "Peanuts" that others have made in other venues( you should identify the sources)And it would be interesting to know which specific collections, from which period in the strip, were read for this article.It would have been interesting to read three collections--one from the early years, one from the sixties and one from the late era(1980's--) and see how the more generally accepted ideas about "Peanuts" are impacted by the changes in the work over the years.
ReplyDelete