Written and Illustrated by Art Spiegelman
Plot Summary
Art Spiegelman, the author and one of
the characters in the comic, depicts the survival story of his
father, Vladek, who suffered through the Holocaust as a Polish Jew.
The action of the comic is divided between war time Poland and the
early 1980's in Rego Park, Queens. Art visits his father and conducts
a series of interviews about his father's life before the outbreak of
World War II, his time spent in the ghettos and hiding from the
Nazis. The first book concludes with Vladek and his wife Anja at the
gates of Auschwitz. The second book focuses mainly on Vladek's life
in the camp, until he was liberated at the conclusion of the war.
Art and Vladek's relationship is
another major theme in the comic book. Burdened by guilt due to his
easy life in America, Art cannot establish a close relationship with
his father. When he was twenty, his mother committed suicide, which
pulled the two men further apart. Vladek eventually remarried,
however he constantly complains to his son that his new wife is only
after his money. Art is frustrated with his father's stubbornness and
excessive frugality. The interviews seem to bring the two men closer
together. Art spends more time with his father and begins to
understand his father's motives for behaving the way he does.
Racial stereotypes are also explored
in this work. Jews are depicted as mice, Germans as cats and Poles
are pigs. Even though Vladek was the victim of discrimination in
Poland, he does not restrain from racism himself. When his daughter
in law picks up a hitch-hiker of African decent, Vladek does not
spare vulgar comments, written in Polish, translated into English
with greater modesty.
Vladek and Anja were married in 1937
and lived in Sosnowiec, Poland. Anja's family was very wealthy and
her father helped the couple to open a successful hosiery factory. At
the outbreak of the war, Vladek is drafted and becomes a prisoner of
war for several months. There is a contrast between the living
conditions of Polish and Jewish prisoners. When he returns home,
stories of Jewish pogroms in Germany terrorize the people. Anja's
aged parents are take away by the Germans, to a “spa” or a
sanatorium for the elderly, however one realizes that was not the
case. Vladek's family wealth is eventually taken over by the Germans
and Vladek and his relatives are forced to live in the ghettos.
Vladek's reputation and popularity among the Jewish people allows him
to aid his family in the difficult living conditions. Vladek and
Anja's little son, Richieu, is sent with a relative to a different
ghetto, where the family had more influential friends. However, as
the Nazis decide to exterminate that ghetto, Richieu is poisoned by
his aunt, along with her other children. Vladek and Anja hide in a
bunker with some other friends as the Nazis collect people to be sent
to the concentration camps. After everybody leaves, Vladek and Anja
escape disguised as Poles, (with pig masks on) and seek a hiding spot
with one of the Polish families. They are turned down by their son's
former governess, but eventually find a safe place in a bran. Vladek
still had jewelry hidden and was able to buy food on the black
market. His outgoings were risky and one time a group of children
were yelling after him, calling him a Jew. However, Vladek's self
control allowed him to convince the parents of those children that in
fact he was a Pole, just like them. Things seem to look up when an
opportunity comes along to escape Poland. Vladek and some of his
friends accept help from a group of Polish men, who promised to get
them safely to Hungary. Unfortunately, the men aimed to give the
group of Jewish hide-outs to the Nazis. The train made a stop at one
of the Polish towns, where Vladek, his wife Anja and their companions
get arrested and sent to Auschwitz immediately.
The second book finally glimpses at
Vladek's despair, when he admits to be “crying a little” at the
beginning of his time in Auschwitz. Luckily, a polish block
supervisor foresaw the end of the war and forthcoming of the Allied
powers. He wanted to learn English, but in order to do so, he needed
someone who could speak both Polish and English. Vladek volunteers
and is rewarded with food and exempt from hard work. Later Vladek
worked as a tin-man fixing roofs all throughout the camp, and was
able to exchange messages and food with Anja. He also made exchanges
with the Poles who worked for the camps but were not prisoners. Many
of them were poor farmers, able to supply food for little pay. Vladek
didn't feel safe working in the tin-shop due to his communist
supervisor and eventually became a shoemaker for the Nazi officers.
Only towards the end of his time in Auschwitz did Vladek engage in
heavy physical work, refereed to as ”Black Work”. It consisted of
carrying heavy stones, digging holes and other laboring tasks.
When news of the Allies approaching
reached the German Officers in Auschwitz they marched the prisoners
to a different camp in Grossen. Later they were transported out of
Poland, up to the north. The prisoners who survived up to this point
were left out in the field, surrounded by German soldiers. During the
night however, the Nazis escaped and left the prisoners to fetch for
themselves. Vladek and his friend find a deserted farm and regain
strength as the Americans, depicted as friendly dogs, appear. Vladek
then takes a long journey back home to Sosnowiec, where he meets
Anja. Together they leave for Sweden, where Art was born. Later the
family immigrated to the United States.
Little is known, or depicted, of
Anja's side of the story. After her death, Vladek burned all of her
dairies and notebooks in despair. During their time at Auschwitz they
had very limited contact, and Vladek claims not to remember much from
their later conversations.
Vladek seems detached from the stories
he tells his son. He simply states what happened, instead of how he
felt and suffered throughout the experience. As readers, we identify
with Art. We can relate to his problems with his father and his life
in New York, but we cannot relate to Vladek's life in war-time
Poland. The Holocaust seems less of a nightmare depicted as a
cartoon, with animals and rodents instead of humans.
Author
Art Spiegelman is best know for his two
volume, award winning graphic novel Maus. Throughout
his career, Spiegelman aimed to establish comics as a serious medium,
equal to fine art. Henry
Kurtzman and Mad
comics had a great influence on his work. Spiegelman lived in San
Francisco in the 1970's and was a part of the Underground
Comix, where he experimented
with the medium. Upon return to New York, he became an editor to the
Raw magazine and
taught at the School of Visual Arts. He began to interview his father
in hopes of creating a graphic novel at that time as well. In the
1990's he worked for The New Yorker.
After
the terrorist attacks of 9-11, Spiegelman started to publish In
the Shadow of No Towers in a
German newspaper, Die Zeit.
In 2004 the work was published as a graphic novel. Currently, Art
Spingerman works with his wife on TOON Books, a series of comic books
for children.
His influence can
be seen in the works of his students, such as Scott McCloud.
Spiegelam believes that comics are best express in diagrammatic and
iconic matter.
Style
The graphic novel
utilizes a simple cartooning style. Black and white rendering of
iconic imagery falls on the bottom right corner of Scott McCloud's
pyramid. It also allows for a masking effect as described in
McCloud's book, where the viewer is able to cast themselves as the
main character. Text and imagery are given equal importance
throughout the work. As Vladek describes this life story, the panels
coincide with what is being said in an additive panel-text
relationship. In some cases however, text specific panels dominate.
Duo-specific and inter-dependent text-panel relationships can also be
ob severed.
Critical
Analysis
Depicting
different ethnic classes as different animals is a tool well unitized
by Spienelman. This allows us to understand the strong antisemitism
present at this time in German occupied Europe. It also creates for a
less upsetting setting. Cats hunting mice is more acceptable than men
hunting men. The simplicity of the illustrations allows the readers
to cast themselves as the main character and engage them with the
story. Spingemal might have depicted the story from his father's
point of view, making him the main character. Instead, the work
takes on a more autobiographical approach while at the same time
introducing more complex themes. It presents an issue of how we, the
next generation is supposed to look at and react to the Holocaust and
it's survivors.
Influence of
Maus And Its Place In History
Maus
is the first comic book to attract scholarly acclaim and win
important awards, such as the Pulitzer Prize. Along with the Watchmen
and The Dark Night Returns, Maus
established the graphic novel, and changed the perception of comics
as aimed strictly at children. In 1992 an exposition of making of
Maus took place at the
Modern Museum of Art, acclaiming comics as fine art in the eyes of
the public.
I thought that Spiegelman portrayed a very desperate and horrible situation in a totally readable way. We can all stomach reading this because they are mice- a species far removed from ours. If this was depicted as it actually happened (to humans), I think that it would be harder to read. Spiegelman has a story that absolutely should be told but he tones it down in this way so that is accessible to everyone so we can all learn about his father's experiences.
ReplyDeleteI think that it is interesting that each ethnicity is represented by a different animal species. Mice would not kill their fellow mice, only a cat would. In this way, we see that perhaps there is something so inherently evil about the Nazi regime that we cannot look at them as being our fellow men, but a different species entirely,
Good report, and an interesting comment. The use of animals has been controversial, but I agree, it allows the reader to identify with the characters, while also allowing one the emotional distance necessary to read a novel about the holocaust. Imagine "Maus" with people and you'll know what I mean--it would become far too horrific,far too bleak, and the other aspects of the story Spiegelman is concerned with relating would diminish in scope. The relationship between father and son is the center of the book. If you want to read more about this period, I recommned Jason Lutes' "Berlin" vols. 1 &2. Lutes tells the story of the people of Berlin in the years leading up to the rise of the Nazis. Fascinating stuff, and in my opinion one of the greatest graphic novels out there.
ReplyDelete